Paulina Jayne’s “Why’d We Ever Leave”: A Resonant Return to Love Lost
By Christian Lamitschka for Country Music News International Magazine
Paulina Jayne has unequivocally announced her presence in the country music landscape with her latest radio-ready single, “Why’d We Ever Leave.” This track, co-written with the esteemed Rob Crosby – a name synonymous with #1 hits for artists like Luke Combs, Lainey Wilson, and Ashley McBryde – is a testament to Jayne’s burgeoning talent and her undeniable chemistry with her collaborators. Crosby himself raves about Jayne, stating, “Paulina Jayne shines among these talents as a rising star. Her voice, her musicianship, her writing talent, and her spirit make her a joy to work with! I’m writing some of the best songs of my career with her. I can’t wait to hear them on the radio, and watch them catch fire on the internet as she releases them!” This high praise from such a seasoned veteran immediately sets a significant bar for “Why’d We Ever Leave,” and thankfully, the song delivers.
The lyrical narrative of “Why’d We Ever Leave” delves into the poignant territory of past lovers grappling with the lingering echoes of a shared history. It’s a raw, honest reflection on what was, and a heartfelt plea to rekindle a flame that, perhaps, never truly extinguished. This universal theme of nostalgia, regret, and the yearning for a second chance is expertly woven into the fabric of the song, making it instantly relatable to anyone who has experienced the bittersweet ache of a love lost. As Paulina herself articulates, “If a Keith Urban track, the feeling of nostalgia, heartache, some 1970s drum sounds, regret and a mid-2000s pop song had a baby, this song would be the byproduct. We’ve all been here – wishing we could go back to something we can’t have anymore. I wrote half of this song driving up I-75N and finished it with the incomparable, Rob Crosby.” This insightful description perfectly encapsulates the song’s unique blend of influences and its emotional core.
Musically, “Why’d We Ever Leave” is a masterclass in nuanced production, a collaborative effort between Paulina Jayne and the highly regarded Mike Hicks (known for his work with Rascal Flatts, Keb’Mo’, and NoBigDyl). The track was meticulously recorded at Welcome to 1979, with Jeremy Bernstein tracking the session alongside assistants Brandon Clark and Ebony Haymer. The final product was expertly mixed by Jackson Badgley and mastered by Sam Moses of Moses Mastering.
The instrumentation is a rich tapestry that perfectly complements the song’s emotional depth. A strong backbeat from Terence Clark anchors the rhythm, providing a solid foundation for the track’s dynamic ebb and flow. Paulina herself showcases her impressive multi-instrumental prowess, contributing a plethora of acoustical instruments that add layers of warmth and authenticity. Quirky electric guitars by Nate Dugger and Jonny Fung inject a modern, almost pop-infused edge, while Steve Mackey’s dynamic low-end bass provides a resonant depth. Mike Hicks’ contribution on keys and B3 lifts the high end, adding a soulful, almost ethereal quality that elevates the song beyond a typical country offering. The fusion of these elements creates a soundscape that is both familiar and fresh, a true testament to the production team’s vision.
A Deeper Look at Paulina Jayne: Beyond the Single
Paulina Jayne is far from an overnight sensation; she’s a seasoned artist whose journey has been marked by significant achievements and high-profile endorsements. Her talent has garnered the attention of industry heavyweights, most notably Ronnie Dunn of Brooks & Dunn, who famously declared, “There’s Dolly Parton junior!” after witnessing Paulina’s performance at Bridgestone Arena, where she opened for none other than Keith Urban and Vince Gill. This comparison alone speaks volumes about Jayne’s stage presence, vocal prowess, and undeniable star quality.
What truly sets Paulina apart is her multifaceted talent. Not only is she a captivating performer with an “energy-infectious, loud-laughing and full of depth personality,” but she is also a prolific songwriter. Her co-writing catalog boasts an impressive roster of #1 hit songwriters, including JT Harding, Shane McAnally, Rob Crosby, Dave Turnbull, Michael Farren, and Billy Montana. This extensive collaboration with some of Nashville’s finest demonstrates her versatility and her ability to craft compelling narratives.
Paulina’s live performances are equally impressive. She has graced the stages of major Live Nation festivals such as Faster Horses and Watershed, and has played renowned venues like The Bluebird Cafe, St. Andrews Hall, and Pine Knob. Her instrumental proficiency is a cornerstone of her artistry; she effortlessly plays guitar, piano, bass, mandolin, and banjo, further showcasing her musical depth. This hands-on approach extends to her production work, as she frequently produces her own music, often in collaboration with Mike Hicks.
In 2024, Paulina Jayne is embracing a relentless release schedule, putting out new music almost every month. This consistent output, coupled with her frequent sneak-peeks on her viral TikTok account, indicates a strategic and modern approach to engaging her growing fanbase. Her dedication and talent have not gone unnoticed, as evidenced by an ASCAP Award, a sponsorship with Ford Motor Company Community Fund, and several music video features on CMT. Beyond her musical pursuits, Paulina is also a proud celebrity ambassador of Miss Amazing, Inc., highlighting her commitment to social causes. Her endorsements from AMI Guitars, G7th Capos, and Bluesman Vintage Guitars further solidify her standing in the industry.
Ultimately, Paulina Jayne is described as “joy personified – a hope-sprung girl and a storytelling woman.” This sentiment perfectly encapsulates the essence of her artistry. “Why’d We Ever Leave” is not just a song; it’s a testament to her vocal prowess, her lyrical sincerity, and her ability to connect with listeners on a deeply emotional level. With the undeniable talent and unwavering support of industry veterans like Rob Crosby, coupled with her strategic approach to releasing new music, Paulina Jayne is poised to become a significant force in country music. “Why’d We Ever Leave” is a powerful opening statement, and the excitement for what she’ll release next is palpable. This song is undoubtedly a strong contender for radio airwaves and a surefire way for Paulina Jayne to “catch fire on the internet.”